Is it better to make pie crust with butter or shortening?

Sharing is caring!

The pros: Shortening has a higher melting point than lard or butter, so it’s easy to incorporate into pie dough and roll out. It’s also helpful when making any kind of decorative pie crust, because doughs made with shortening hold their shape the best during baking.

What fat makes the best pie crust? The best way to experiment with lard in pie dough is to use it in some combination with butter. Start with a proportion of about 70 percent butter, 30 percent lard. You should end up with a crust that features the best of both fats—gorgeous flakes from the lard and rich flavor from the butter.

What makes a pie crust tough? Your crust is too tough. If your pie crust is tough instead of tender and flaky, you probably either overworked the dough or added too much water to it. There’s not much to do in this situation but plate up a slice and throw on a scoop of ice cream. Don’t sweat it: You’ll do better next time.

Is lard or butter better for pie crust? Pie crusts made with lard are flaky and crisp, while all-butter crusts have rich flavor and tenderness. Lard has a higher melting point than butter, making pastry easier to work with. Butter’s lower melting point absorbs more quickly into flour requiring colder pastry and quick work to retain flakiness.

What is a trick to making a good pie crust?

10 Tips for Making Perfect Pie Crust

  1. Use Very Cold Butter or Fat. …
  2. Retain Some Chunks. …
  3. Limit the Water. …
  4. Chill the Dough. …
  5. Roll the Dough, Turn the Dough. …
  6. Think Curbs, Not Driveways. …
  7. Let the Dough Fall Into the Pan. …
  8. Chill the Lined Pie Pan.

Is it better to make pie crust with butter or shortening? – Related Asked Question

Is oil or butter better for pie crust?

Because butter has a higher melting point, it also melts nicely in your mouth. The milkfats present in the butter also allow the crust to brown more than shortening, lard, or oil-based versions. Oil: Oil has one major benefit — as a fat in liquid form, it can’t be melted and is easy to incorporate into dough.

Why do you put vinegar in pie crust?

Vinegar helps tenderize pie dough because it slightly inhibits gluten development, leading to a crust that is flakier and easier to work with. The great thing about vinegar is that you really only need a little bit of it to help your dough, so you won’t know what that “secret ingredient” after baking!

How do you keep pie crust from getting tough?

Roll, roll, scrape and turn. Roll, roll, roll, scrape and turn. This prevents the dough from getting stuck to the work surface.

Caption Options

  1. Chill. Cold butter is a key to pie dough success. …
  2. Pulse, Pulse, Pulse. …
  3. Get It Wet. …
  4. Gather. …
  5. Chill, Again. …
  6. Roll.

What does an egg do in a pie crust?

Egg: This makes the dough more pliable and easy to roll out. Eggs also make the crust more compact. Acid and Alcohol: Both acid and alcohol tenderize pie dough, make it easier to roll out, and prevent it from shrinking in your pan.

Why should pie dough not be stretched when putting in pie?

Why is this important? Because pastry dough that’s stretched to fit a pan will try like heck to revert to its original size as it bakes. If you’ve stretched a too-small round of dough to cover the pan, it’ll most likely shrink down the sides of the pan, disappearing into the filling as the pie bakes. FAIL.

What are three kitchen tools that helped in making a good pie crust?

The Fundamentals:

  • Multi-Unit Measuring Cups. Precise measurements of both dry and wet ingredients, like flour and water, are necessary for pie, and this OXO product makes it easy to do all in one place. …
  • Measuring Cups. …
  • Measuring Spoons. …
  • Food Processor. …
  • Dough Blender. …
  • Mixing Bowls. …
  • Rolling Pin.

Are Crisco and shortening the same thing?

You’ve probably heard of Crisco, which is a well-known brand of shortening that has been around since 1911. Shortening and other solid fats are preferable to liquid oils in baking applications like cookies, pie crusts, and cakes to create a tender, flaky end product.

What are the 2 characteristics of a good pie crust?

American pie crust is made with a medium flake pastry. The following are characteristics of a good pie: Crust is evenly browned and golden brown around the edge, somewhat lighter brown on bottom. Crust is flaky and tender.

Can you use milk instead of water for pie crust?

The more fat you’ve got in your crust, the better it will taste and the better its texture. We use European-style cultured butter with a butterfat content of at least 83 percent. We also use whole milk instead of water—another way to inject more fat into the crust, and a key ingredient for getting it super flaky.

Should pie dough be chilled before rolling?

Cover the pie dough with plastic wrap and chill at least 30 minutes before rolling it out. This lets the liquid absorb into the dough, firms the fat and allows the gluten to relax.

What are the two keys to making good pastry dough?

There are two keys to making good pastry dough: Avoid gluten development as much as possible since excessive gluten will make for a very dense, tough texture. The lower water content and minimal manipulation of the dough both help reduce gluten development.

What happens if you put too much butter in a pie crust?

When put into the oven, the small chunks of butter inside the dough will create little steam pockets, and where the solid butter once was becomes an air pocket, thus creating a tender flaky crust. If the butter chunks are too big, you’ll have melted butter leaking from your pie crust as it bakes.

What is the advantage of milk over water in making pie pastry?

So milk will have three effects: a (slightly) lower rise, a (slightly) more tender texture and a (noticeably) darker crust.

Why is my pie crust cracking when I roll it out?

Chilled pie dough cracks when rolled out

Dough was too cold or not kneaded enough, making the edges of the dough disk ragged and dry. Also, the dough may not have rested enough to allow the flour to hydrate evenly. If there are many cracks and the edges seem dry, gather the dough into a ball.

Why do you put salt in pie crust?

Salt counteracts bitterness so adding just a little can make the perception of sweetness. Salt adds flavor and dimension to baked goods. If your pie crust is flat and bland tasting, chances are you did not use salt in the dough.

How do I make my bottom pie crust crispy?

Coating the surface of the bottom crust will create a barrier to prevent sogginess. Adding a layer of corn syrup or a slightly beaten egg white before pouring in the filling will form a seal between the pie dough and the filling and will help make the crust crisp and flaky.

Should I bake the bottom pie crust first?

But the one surefire way to make absolutely certain your pie’s crust will be golden brown, crisp, and delicious — just as appealing as its filling — is to prebake it. That’s right: bake the bottom crust first, before adding the filling.

Should I Sift flour for pie crust?

Don’t sift the flour: I sift flour for cakes, but not for pies. A pie crust should be dense, and the processor will break the flour up enough for that. Stir to blend the flour, sugar, spices, and salt in a bowl or blend them with the steel blade in a processor or flat paddle in a mixer.

What are the two most common fats to make pie crust?

Oil and margarine are the two most common fats used to make pie crust.

Why did my pie crust melt in the oven?

A: This happens for a few reasons. The first possibility is that your pie crust wasn’t chilled enough. If the butter is too soft, your crust will melt before it has a chance to actually bake. Pie crusts must be chilled before baking.

What does lemon juice do in pie crust?

A little acid goes a long way: Add a little acid to your dough. Whether it be fresh lemon juice or apple cider vinegar, acid retards gluten development. One teaspoon will do the job, and it can replace some of the water you add.

How do you keep pie crust from sticking to the pie plate?

One of the most effective things you can do is submerge the bottom of your pie plate into some hot water for around 10 to 20 seconds. Doing this helps to re-melt any solidified butter, greasing up the pan again, and releasing the crust from sticking to the pan.

Should I grease glass pie plate?

Do not oil or grease glass pie plates. Thin, aluminum pie pans are a poor choice because they cook unevenly. If you have to use them, double them up and use two. Dull metal pie plates are better than shiny metal pans for making pies.

What is a pie crust protector?

A pie crust shield is a baking tool that covers the outer edge of a pie to keep it from over-browning or burning while the pie bakes.

What products are good for pie?

Recommended Products: Dermalex Repair, Skinmedica TNS Ceramide Treatment Cream, CeraVe Daily Moisturizing Lotion, COSRX Balancium Comfort Ceramide Cream.

What is needed to bake a pie?

8 Essential Tools for Baking Pies

  1. WIRE RACK. A pie needs to be totally cool before it’s sliced. …
  2. PASTRY BRUSH. Use a dry one to brush flour off rolled dough, or dip it in egg or cream wash to glaze the crust.
  3. OVEN THERMOMETER. …
  4. WOODEN ROLLING PIN. …
  5. RIMMED BAKING SHEET. …
  6. ALUMINUM FOIL. …
  7. DRIED BEANS OR RICE. …
  8. GLASS PIE DISH.

Sharing is caring!